My favorites right now are Kellie Pickler and Ace. Kellie is just so DAMN CUTE! Her personality is without a doubt the best on the show. And Ace, I mean come on he’s HOT and also has a very good voice. I was VERY impressed how well he did with Michael Jackson’s song “Butterflies”, not an easy good with all the falsetto’s. I do like Kevin, HOWEVER I don't think he'll make it far in the top 12. I also like Taylor Hicks... something about him is so interesting to watch and listen to.I was VERY happy to see Ayla go home... she SOO ruined one of my favorite songs right now, "Written".And for all you people who came into this thread bashing the show... that's cool you dislike and don't watch it, but there are fans like us who like the show and like to discus what's going on. And not to be mean, but what's the point of coming into this thread that's about a discussion of your favorite on a show, and degrade that show? Not exactly productive. Again I am not trying to be mean, it's just frustrating to read through a thread and have people degrade something the original poster was being positive about.
-
American Idol
-
- Ace? Come on Eddie. Good looking, yeah. Talented, not so much.2. Bucky. Should've been sent back to the trailer a long time ago. (That was harsh, Damien!)3. Taylor and Elliott - those are my boys.4. I agree. It's not necessary for us to read how much people hate American Idol. If you wanna do that, start an I Hate American Idol thread.5. And I'm gonna say this only once. Have some discernment please. Learn to distinguish the difference between this and that. American Idol is NOT a reality show. It's a game show. There's a difference. Cops and The Real World are "reality shows". American Idol, The Amazing Race, and Who Wants to Be a Millionaire are game shows. Survivor and Big Brother are a mixture of the two. Get it right or I will send you to the principals office!
-
>1. Ace? Come on Eddie. Good looking, yeah. Talented, not so much.
Now see I think Ace has a good voice. Is it the best on the show.. I don't think so.
>2. Bucky. Should've been sent back to the trailer a long time ago. (That was harsh, Damien!)
ROFL!! Harsh but so damned true!!
>3. Taylor and Elliott - those are my boys.
I definitely like Taylor; he's so just darn fun!! BUT Elliot... sorry there is just something I don't like about him. I am not saying he's a bad singer, but there is something holding me back from liking him... maybe that'll change.
I also really like Mandisa... now SHE CAN SING! I always look forward to her performance.
-
I think Elliot is by far the best singer on the show. Possibly the best male singer they've ever had. Remember when he did "Moody's Mood for Love"? Manomanoman! Amazing! I acually found that performance to download last night. I think this is definitely gonna be a guy's year. I predict the winner will be either Chris, Elliot, or possibly Taylor.
-
I'll make my say in this conversation since Will Makar goes to my school and was voted off last week. Aceand Chris Daughtry are overrated. They really aren't that hot and they aren't the best singers out there. Gideon should not have gone home. He's one of the best and undoubtedly has one of the best voices there. I won't say much about the girls because I've only been watching to root for Will. Taylor Hicks is awesome. He isn't the best singer, so I wouldn't vote for him, but I love his mannerisms. Kevin has a church type of voice and he isn't really my type of person for music listening-to. He does look strangely a lot like Chicken Little, though. Bucky isn't a good singer. His voice is okay, but there's no body to it; it's just hollow.
-
Now see I think there are a few girls that are going to give the guys a run for the win... like Kellie and Mandisa. I think we are going to see Kellie really grow through the competition.
-
I will admit i was sad to see Will go home, I actually really liked him. Kevin honestly should have been the one going home, I would like to have seen what Will would have brought to the show.
-
In reply to: 2. Bucky. Should've been sent back to the trailer a long time ago. That was way harsh! lol. I know he cant sing that well, but I feel compelled to like him...he's like a scruffy, scraggly little puppy, you just gotta love him.I dont get the hype about paris. I find her a bit annoying.
-
What?! I love Kevin. He needs more stage presence but his voice is really good.
-
I like Kellie too, although her little southern naive schtick is getting old. I think her problem is that she's too much like Carrie Underwood.I also think Mandisa is amazing. I predict that either her or that amazing McPhee chick will be the last girl standing. But I still think it's a guy's game this year. In reply to: What?! I love Kevin. He needs more stage presence but his voice is really good. My thoughts exactly. I think the image consultants will help him a great deal. I think we'll be surprised at how he turns out.
-
it might be just me but i think bucky looks like britney spears
-
Ahahah!! What did we all think of last nights show?
-
There wasn't anybody on last nights show that really stood out. That chris guy I thought did pretty good but overall the show kinda bored me.
-
Tonight was appaling. Absolutely appaling.When Ryan said "Lisa" instead of "Bucky" I knew it had all gone to hell. As for the bottom three - it should have been Ace that got sent packing.
-
Oh come on now.. BUCKY really should have been the one packing. I really thought his performace was the worst, bored me out of my pants.Reallly this week no one did all that great. It was a hard music genre to fill.Hopefulyl next week will be better!
-
I agree totally.I was just saying that, out of the bottom three, it should have been Ace.
-
Kevin should have gone home.. He really isnt that great. I really liked melissa.. but who forgets the words!!?
-
She was losing it in the end too though.
-
For sure. I couldn't watch it, It was too boring
-
Oh Bob how can you diss the duo who brought us, "Lets get ready to rumble""!!!!!It's brill
I love Mandisa (sp?) she is fantastic (is she still in??)