I just want some

---

The fact that the kid "doesn't seem to have minded" is irrelevant. The simple fact is the sister is guilty of a serious crime.
I agree with Chance. 30 years of muff-diving.
(sound of gavel on wood)

You are arguing that something should be illegal because it is illegal; and that all infringements of the law should be treated with equal severity.

You might consider that, for example, in Utah all sex outside marriage is illegal.

Laws are made by people - sometimes, stupid people. They are not pronouncements from God. They ought to be based on what is needed for the protection of people, and whether there is a victim or not is not only relevant, but goes right to the core of the purpose of laws.

I don't really think this is the time to have a philosophical debate on whether or not it should be illegal for a 20-some year old woman to have sex with her brother who is a little boy.The fact is, it is illegal.And it should be.Surely you're not going to assert that there could be any kind of rationalization for this kind of behavior...

I'm sorry, it just gets my goat when people think the solution to everything they don't like is to throw someone (always someone else they don't know, never themselves or their families or friends, of course) into prison for thirty years. In a situation like this it would make things infinitely worse for everyone. Sometimes the best thing all round is not to enforce the law. The punitive apparatus of the state is not the right solution to every problem.How many guys were shown how to masturbate by their older brothers? Shall we throw them all into prison? Quite frankly, though this was most unwise, I think it is miles away from rape.

Well, if nothing else, I think what you've done is sort've served as a tempering voice. I think I get you. On reading the OP again, he only talked about getting some "boob action" and showering together. While I still contend (and I think you agree)that this is grossly inappropriate for an adult sister, it probably doesn't rise to the level of 30 years in the slammer.I guess spending my days with kids who have actually been sexually abused by family members somehow causes me to be cautious and concerned and compassionate to the point where I over-react to posts like that.But the sister does need to have her ass kicked!

Thanks, damien. I'm only asking that people use discernment rather than knee-jerk judgements. I haven't had as wide a contact as you have with people who have been grossly sexually abused by family members, but I have had some, and it's ugly indeed, a blight on a life that hangs on and on. My feeling is that if we treat everything the same we are unjust to everyone. It's no respect to those whose life has been made a daily hell through their childhood.

You forgot that blow jobs are illegal here too.
Toss me in prison, Love having my dick sucked, I rather enjoy licking her snatch, and I dont have a problem or aversion to popping it in her pooper nad I love even standard regular sex, and as of yet Im nto married.

The biggest thing I think that should be concentrated on in this case is that its not like they were 12 and 13 and playing doctor, shes an adult, he was a child. He was RAPED. He isnt old enough to give consent. The incest is an added bonus charge, the real crime is the child molesting that she did as her age with her brother.
If she would do that to a brother, a close loved one, what has/would she do with a kid that lived down the lane?
Personally, had I been molested by a hot girl down the street when I was 12 Id of been good and dandy with it, but that doesnt make it right.

That's absolutely disgusting.Your sister is a child predator; you should at least bring this to your parents attention, even years after the fact.For a brother and sister to mess around when they're both young, is wrong and possibly emotionally damaging (You might believe it's okay)But when shes a supposed resposible "adult", its called incestual molestation. It's illegal.And wrong for that matter.That disgusts me.

While i agree that it is totally wrong, i dont think that the boy feeling his sisters boobs is rape. By the sounds of it, i highly doubt he was forced to do it either.

As far as the law would be concerned, 'consent' from a minor is irrelevant (except in sentencing decisions) Rape is an old blanket term as well (A couple of countries don't even have 'rape' in their laws anymore) At the worst, it could be sexual assault on a minor, sexual interference too. Over-all, at this point, I think we can all put down the torches and pitch forks against his sister. She did something VERY stupid, and I'd be more inclined to believe she may have a cognitive disorder, rather than evil intentions of "child rape"